Thursday, 19 November 2026 | Asia's First Monthly Magazine on e-Governance · Est. 2005
SAS Digital Sovereignty
Gujarat AI Summit
SAS Digital Sovereignty
Gujarat AI Summit
Live — 2,072 transfers tracked Updated 19-11-2026, 15:12
Live
Transfer MHA transfers three AGMUT cadre IAS officers from Delhi to J&K Today Transfer Karnataka government transfers 26 IPS officers in major reshuffle Today Retirement Anurag Agarwal takes charge as Meghalaya Acting DGP after Nongrang retires Today Deputation J&K transfers JKAS officer Sabha Sarwar on deputation to Ladakh 1d ago Transfer Maharashtra reshuffles three senior IAS officers across Mantralaya departments 1d ago Transfer Uttarakhand reshuffles six IAS officers, Nitesh Kumar Jha named Secretary Urban Development 1d ago Appointment Malay Jain Named Balaghat SP in Madhya Pradesh IPS 7d ago Appointment Ajay Kumar Yadav Appointed CRPF Additional Director General 11d ago Promotion Punjab Elevates Four Senior IPS Officers to DGP Rank 11d ago Appointment K. Lakshmipriya Named GBA Special Commissioner, Karnataka 12d ago Transfer Bihar Home Department transfers Khagaria SP Bhanu Pratap Singh to Police Headquarters 14d ago Transfer Jharkhand transfers seven IAS officers, Anup Garg named Joint Secretary in Building Construction 14d ago Appointment Girish S.N. Named Odisha Health Commissioner-Secretary 14d ago Extension Maharashtra reshuffles 16 police officers, three Thane seniors get one-year extension 15d ago Posting Shailendra Kumar gets interim charge of J&K Chief Secretary post 15d ago Transfer Uttar Pradesh transfers two IPS officers across Noida and Kanpur Nagar commissionerates 16d ago Resignation Madhya Pradesh IPS officer Anurag Sujania resigns four days after transfer from Sagar 16d ago Transfer Tamil Nadu transfers three central prison superintendents amid escape incidents 16d ago Transfer Bihar Reshuffles Four Senior IAS Officers Across Key Departments 16d ago Posting 1991-Batch IAS Officer CK Anil Takes Charge as Bihar Education ACS 16d ago Transfer Odisha IPS Reshuffle: Jail DG Sushant Nath Moved to Home Department as OSD 16d ago Transfer J&K Reshuffles 12 IAS, IPS and JKAS Officers Across Key Departments 16d ago Transfer UP IAS Reshuffle: Alok Kumar-II Becomes IIDC, 15 Officers Moved 16d ago Transfer Kerala Reshuffles 35 IAS Officers, Jyothilal Gets Home Department 16d ago Transfer Karnataka Transfers 9 Officers; Latha R. Appointed Housing Board Commissioner 19 Oct Transfer UP Transfers 7 IAS Officers; Dhirendra Singh Sachan Gets Panchayati Raj Charge 19 Oct Transfer Delhi Assigns New Roles to 3 IAS Officers; Nandini Paliwal Gets Power Department 19 Oct Transfer MP Transfers 4 IAS Officers; Ramprakash Ahirwar Gets Bhopal Municipal Commissioner Post 19 Oct Transfer Andhra Pradesh Transfers 11 IAS Officers; B. Anil Kumar Reddy Gets Industries Post 13 Oct Appointment Centre Approves 26 Senior Appointments; Manisha Trighatia Gets Urban Development Role 12 Oct

Hover a headline to pause it · drag the rail to scrub · ← → to step · Space to pause

Bill to Escalate UIDAI as a Statutory Authority….. a Correct Move in the Right Direction

In May 2012 this columnist insisted that UID initiative had been underestimated for its potential to bring a sea change in the way citizen-centric government service delivery usually get designed in our country. It was further opined that this may be the first and most necessary step towards a connected government. Since that last 18 months we increasingly observed that one by one important flagship government welfare schemes and financial agencies have started adopting UID as an important enabling instrument to fulfill the respective objective of the projects or the schemes.


UIDAI, created in 2009 as an Executive Authority for 5 years, had its shares of criticism like many other large government initiatives, be it for sluggish implementation, sub-optimal funding, unreliable output, confusion over redundancy with NPR activity or doubted usability. The situation was bit stabilized after the then FM’s 2011 budget speech with the declaration that UIDAI would go for 600 million enumeration in next 2-3 years and from October 2011, at least 1 million Aadhaar number would be generated per day.

After 24 months of that declaration, it may be prudent to review the current status of the UID programme output. It is obvious that 600 million target has not been achieved by this time. UIDAI may have its explanations for this slow progress on the assurance given in the Parliament but there are some important points scored by them in this intervening period. The most impacting of these is the decision of the Union Cabinet to escalate the legal status of the UIDAI to a Statutory Authority against its existing Executive Authority.


It is important to appreciate the long-standing consequence of this all important government decision. The UID project has been censured by many as a very costly proposition for a developing country of 1200 million population while some other experts doubted for any positive outcome from its benefit-cost analysis, especially in the back-drop of the constitutionally mandated National Population Register (NPR) related parallel activities wherein every Indian citizen has to be identified and some details to be recorded. In my opinion, in the excitement of branding the UID initiative as a poor duplication of NPR, most of the UIDAI critics missed the perceived primary objective of the UID project, to be used as an effective instrument to control resource leakage.


For many wide-ranging government welfare schemes correct identification of millions of beneficiaries of those schemes across the country may simply save, over a few years, the leakage in scarce government resources to the extent of the amount government would be spending over a span of 6-7 years to map those beneficiaries through the UID initiative. However the steel-frame mindset of the executives in the concerned government departments did struggle in the beginning to appreciate this overwhelming potential of the UIDAI in supplementing the stated objectives of their own welfare schemes.

Presumably, the mandate and possible outcome of the UIDAI did not appear with clarity before them and moreover it was felt that UIDAI did not have adequate legal backing to modify or adapt in to the implementation framework of any individual scheme initiated by the concerned government departments. Perhaps added to this uncanny worry is the fact that the entire programme is being steered by a person, with formidable authority bestowed on him, who had no exposure to government functioning for initial decades of his distinguished career!


There are other issues with the UID programme, like serious doubt raised by activists indicating possible misuse of data as well breach in privacy while political opposition started spreading around when government indicated that schemes related to Direct Benefit Transfer would necessarily use Aadhaar-linked bank accounts of the identified beneficiaries. Journey of the Aadhaar programme, since the day of the Executive Order in January 2009, has thus been a chequered ride, firstly in the form of the Bill entitled ‘National Identification Authority of India’ placed in Lok Sabha in December 2010, thereafter scrutiny by Parliament Standing Committee on Finance and then tabling of the PSC report in Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha in December 2011, besides juxtaposing its utility against NPR.

However, presumably, the recent decision of the Union Cabinet for introduction of the National Identification Authority of India Bill, 2013 in the forthcoming winter session of Parliament by the Planning Ministry, after incorporating some recommendations of the PSC, appeared to have been taken after the Supreme Court’s recent observation that Aadhaar number cannot be mandatory for government schemes, in response to a PIL against transfer of the cooking LPG subsidy through Aadhaar number-linked bank accounts. Now the proposed Bill, through the Act of Parliament, would seek to convert the existing UIDAI into a statutory authority to provide astute legal backing and also would outline the powers and functions of the Authority including other important matters like offences and penalties.

It is said that it is better late than never. And all is getting increasingly well for the UIDAI after few administrative and financial hiccups, usual for a large programme of this nature and scale. Large projects like PDS, MNREGS, IAY, JSY, ASHA, ICDS etc. have already started using Aadhaar as one of their enablers. For financial inclusion initiatives Aadhaar is fast becoming the only KYC parameter. More than 480 millions of Aadhaar numbers have been generated to date. It is learnt that benefit-cost analysis by National Institute of Public Finance and Policy revealed substantial benefits out of UID initiative with an IRR of 52.85%. Now comes the constitutional backing what is badly needed. As I wrote in May 2012, UIDAI is destined to be the most impacting transformational initiative in the governance paradigm. Let us wait and observe…time is the essence for the UID initiative.

Ashis Sanyal
Consulting Editor, egov

EN
Written by

Elets News Network

Elets News Network reports on governance, public policy and digital government across India.

IAS Transfer Tracker

Live — 2,072 transfers tracked Updated 19-11-2026, 15:12

The eGov Weekly Briefing

A weekly round-up of governance news, interviews and policy analysis — in your inbox.