Wednesday, 18 November 2026 | Asia's First Monthly Magazine on e-Governance · Est. 2005
SAS Digital Sovereignty
Gujarat AI Summit
SAS Digital Sovereignty
Gujarat AI Summit
Live — 2,069 transfers tracked Updated 18-11-2026, 14:46
Live
Deputation J&K transfers JKAS officer Sabha Sarwar on deputation to Ladakh Today Transfer Maharashtra reshuffles three senior IAS officers across Mantralaya departments Today Transfer Uttarakhand reshuffles six IAS officers, Nitesh Kumar Jha named Secretary Urban Development Today Appointment Malay Jain Named Balaghat SP in Madhya Pradesh IPS 5d ago Appointment Ajay Kumar Yadav Appointed CRPF Additional Director General 9d ago Promotion Punjab Elevates Four Senior IPS Officers to DGP Rank 10d ago Appointment K. Lakshmipriya Named GBA Special Commissioner, Karnataka 11d ago Transfer Bihar Home Department transfers Khagaria SP Bhanu Pratap Singh to Police Headquarters 13d ago Transfer Jharkhand transfers seven IAS officers, Anup Garg named Joint Secretary in Building Construction 13d ago Appointment Girish S.N. Named Odisha Health Commissioner-Secretary 13d ago Extension Maharashtra reshuffles 16 police officers, three Thane seniors get one-year extension 14d ago Posting Shailendra Kumar gets interim charge of J&K Chief Secretary post 14d ago Transfer Uttar Pradesh transfers two IPS officers across Noida and Kanpur Nagar commissionerates 14d ago Resignation Madhya Pradesh IPS officer Anurag Sujania resigns four days after transfer from Sagar 14d ago Transfer Tamil Nadu transfers three central prison superintendents amid escape incidents 14d ago Transfer Bihar Reshuffles Four Senior IAS Officers Across Key Departments 14d ago Posting 1991-Batch IAS Officer CK Anil Takes Charge as Bihar Education ACS 14d ago Transfer Odisha IPS Reshuffle: Jail DG Sushant Nath Moved to Home Department as OSD 15d ago Transfer J&K Reshuffles 12 IAS, IPS and JKAS Officers Across Key Departments 15d ago Transfer UP IAS Reshuffle: Alok Kumar-II Becomes IIDC, 15 Officers Moved 15d ago Transfer Kerala Reshuffles 35 IAS Officers, Jyothilal Gets Home Department 15d ago Transfer Karnataka Transfers 9 Officers; Latha R. Appointed Housing Board Commissioner 30d ago Transfer UP Transfers 7 IAS Officers; Dhirendra Singh Sachan Gets Panchayati Raj Charge 30d ago Transfer Delhi Assigns New Roles to 3 IAS Officers; Nandini Paliwal Gets Power Department 30d ago Transfer MP Transfers 4 IAS Officers; Ramprakash Ahirwar Gets Bhopal Municipal Commissioner Post 30d ago Transfer Andhra Pradesh Transfers 11 IAS Officers; B. Anil Kumar Reddy Gets Industries Post 13 Oct Appointment Centre Approves 26 Senior Appointments; Manisha Trighatia Gets Urban Development Role 12 Oct Transfer J&K Transfers 49 IAS, JKAS Officers; Mamta Yadav Gets Information Department 12 Oct Transfer Chhattisgarh Transfers 18 IPS Officers; Jha Amankumar Ramankumar Gets SIA Charge 10 Oct Transfer Delhi Transfers 34 IAS, DANICS Officers; Awanish Kumar Gets Excise Charge 9 Oct

Hover a headline to pause it · drag the rail to scrub · ← → to step · Space to pause

Home · News

Because Policy is Judged by Results, not Intentions

Digital Learning has initiated discussion on ‘ICT in Education Policy’ in the month of September 2006, which stimulated a number of views, voices and visions from all parts of the globe. Catching up the same thread, Dr Utpal Mallik, the Head of Department of Computer Education in NCERT, shares his views.


In the use of ICTs in school education, there is a clear pattern across a large number of developing countries. Primary and secondary data from these countries give no indication that effective interactions between policies and practices are very common. The impact of ICT use on learning outcomes is still unclear, and is open to debate. But ICTs are being increasingly used in education, even in difficult circumstances. And ‘scaling up’ of those initiatives is common. But the models for scaling up are varied and few of them are based on monitoring and evaluation data. The best practices and lessons learnt from them are rarely recorded for policy analysis. The rhetoric and rationale for using ICTs focus on the potential of the technology for bringing about changes in the teaching-learning paradigm. In practice, ICT-uses in schools are, at best, add-on activities that have little consequence on teaching-learning. Prevalent ICT uses do not help classroom practices adopt new technology tools. By and large, ICT efforts are restricted to procurement of equipment and getting connectivity for school computer labs. In other words, building infrastructure is the primary activity, when it is not the only activity.

This does not transform teaching-learning into an engaging and active process connected to real life nor does it prepare young people for tomorrow’s workplace. This general picture in nearly a hundred countries (India not included) makes a strong case for a feedback mechanism for mutual adjustments between the policy and practices everywhere.


Look outside the school boundary. At the turn of the new millennium, there were 113 million out of school children throughout the world. Out of them, 110 million were from developing countries. One hundred fifty million did not complete the primary school. ICT offered them little. Yet, the expectation is still very high. “We recognise that while ICT may be a luxury for the rich, for us, the poor countries, it is a vital and essential tool for fighting poverty and ensuring our survival”, says Prime Minister Meles Zenawi of Ethiopia (2005). Kofi Annan appeals, “we must ensure that information and communication technologies are used to unlock the door to education” (2005). In the context of developing countries, these expectations can be translated into tangible outcomes, like increase in the access to education through distance learning, integration of the technology into the educational processes to meet larger goals, rather than using it in isolation or as something nailed onto the education system. Enabling a knowledge network for school goers, training of teachers, increasing availability of quality education materials, enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of educational administration – there are many ways to enhance educational opportunities and enrich learning experiences using the technology.


The question of priority is vital. Back home, Shastri Bhawan’s advice to the Planning Commission (July 2006), asking the latter to plan for universal secondary education and forget a laptop for every child, was based on a singular decision of the Human Resource Development Ministry.

There is one inherent danger in technology integration in the education system. Just as outdated medicines are no longer effective and yet they find their way into health care systems in the third world, past due ICT tools and methodologies may be recycled for use in the developing countries. As the growth in ICT markets slows in the developed world, materials and methods that didn’t work there may well be exported to education markets in developing countries, whether or not those are relevant to the problems of education in these parts of the world. The expectation that computers can solve what is wrong with education adds to the danger.


If policy advice related to ICT use in education is to be realistic, it needs to be backed up by a rich database of lessons learnt. So it is important that monitoring and evaluation of all efforts are undertaken, involving all stakeholders

EN
Written by

Elets News Network

Elets News Network reports on governance, public policy and digital government across India.

IAS Transfer Tracker

Live — 2,069 transfers tracked Updated 18-11-2026, 14:46

The eGov Weekly Briefing

A weekly round-up of governance news, interviews and policy analysis — in your inbox.