Wednesday, 18 November 2026 | Asia's First Monthly Magazine on e-Governance · Est. 2005
SAS Digital Sovereignty
Gujarat AI Summit
SAS Digital Sovereignty
Gujarat AI Summit
Live — 2,066 transfers tracked Updated 12-11-2026, 22:25
Live
Appointment Malay Jain Named Balaghat SP in Madhya Pradesh IPS 5d ago Appointment Ajay Kumar Yadav Appointed CRPF Additional Director General 9d ago Promotion Punjab Elevates Four Senior IPS Officers to DGP Rank 10d ago Appointment K. Lakshmipriya Named GBA Special Commissioner, Karnataka 11d ago Transfer Bihar Home Department transfers Khagaria SP Bhanu Pratap Singh to Police Headquarters 12d ago Transfer Jharkhand transfers seven IAS officers, Anup Garg named Joint Secretary in Building Construction 12d ago Appointment Girish S.N. Named Odisha Health Commissioner-Secretary 13d ago Extension Maharashtra reshuffles 16 police officers, three Thane seniors get one-year extension 13d ago Posting Shailendra Kumar gets interim charge of J&K Chief Secretary post 13d ago Transfer Uttar Pradesh transfers two IPS officers across Noida and Kanpur Nagar commissionerates 14d ago Resignation Madhya Pradesh IPS officer Anurag Sujania resigns four days after transfer from Sagar 14d ago Transfer Tamil Nadu transfers three central prison superintendents amid escape incidents 14d ago Transfer Bihar Reshuffles Four Senior IAS Officers Across Key Departments 14d ago Posting 1991-Batch IAS Officer CK Anil Takes Charge as Bihar Education ACS 14d ago Transfer Odisha IPS Reshuffle: Jail DG Sushant Nath Moved to Home Department as OSD 14d ago Transfer J&K Reshuffles 12 IAS, IPS and JKAS Officers Across Key Departments 15d ago Transfer UP IAS Reshuffle: Alok Kumar-II Becomes IIDC, 15 Officers Moved 15d ago Transfer Kerala Reshuffles 35 IAS Officers, Jyothilal Gets Home Department 15d ago Transfer Karnataka Transfers 9 Officers; Latha R. Appointed Housing Board Commissioner 29d ago Transfer UP Transfers 7 IAS Officers; Dhirendra Singh Sachan Gets Panchayati Raj Charge 30d ago Transfer Delhi Assigns New Roles to 3 IAS Officers; Nandini Paliwal Gets Power Department 30d ago Transfer MP Transfers 4 IAS Officers; Ramprakash Ahirwar Gets Bhopal Municipal Commissioner Post 30d ago Transfer Andhra Pradesh Transfers 11 IAS Officers; B. Anil Kumar Reddy Gets Industries Post 13 Oct Appointment Centre Approves 26 Senior Appointments; Manisha Trighatia Gets Urban Development Role 12 Oct Transfer J&K Transfers 49 IAS, JKAS Officers; Mamta Yadav Gets Information Department 12 Oct Transfer Chhattisgarh Transfers 18 IPS Officers; Jha Amankumar Ramankumar Gets SIA Charge 10 Oct Transfer Delhi Transfers 34 IAS, DANICS Officers; Awanish Kumar Gets Excise Charge 9 Oct Transfer Odisha Transfers 7 IAS Officers; New Collectors Appointed in Nabarangpur, Nuapada 8 Oct Transfer Karnataka Transfers 6 Officers; Nagaraja N.M. Gets Social Welfare Charge 8 Oct Transfer UP Government Transfers 15 IAS, 23 PCS Officers; Mala Srivastava Gets New Charge 6 Oct

Hover a headline to pause it · drag the rail to scrub · ← → to step · Space to pause

Home · News

Patients Get Powerful

Public complaints against malpractices of private hospitals and nursing homes overinflating bills by performing unneccessary or additional surgical procedures within a scheduled operation is often  been heard of …but hopefully, not any more!


In a path-breaking ruling, the Supreme Court has levied legal obligation on all hospitals and nursing homes to get formal consent of patients before subjecting them to any surgery. Exceptional allowance may be given in such conditions that are life-threating for the partient and/or have considerable medical consequences. Under normal circumstances, if any additional surgical procedure is deemed necessary during the course of a scheduled operation, the medical team will need to wait till the patient regains consciousness and gives his/her consent for the same.

Uptil now, additional surgical procedures used to be performed with consent from relatives of the patient, while he/she was still at the operation theatre. Often, such situations were exploited to unneccessarily increase the billing amount, causing financial damage to patients and their families.


This ruling came in context of a case dating back to 1995, where a female patient was operated upon for removing her ovaries, while undergoing a diagnostic procedure at a private hospital.  Although the court was agreeable to the fact that the operation was done for benefit of the patient, it held that it was done without consent of the patient, resulting in permanent disability to attain motherhood.


While announcing the judgement, Justices B N Aggarwal, P P Naolekar and R V Raveendran underlined the need for ‘informed consent’ from patients as a legally binding pre-requisite for all surgical interventions. The bench laid out a detailed guideline for doctors on “prior consent for additional procedures”. It was held that such a move will safeguard innocent citizens from getting duped in the hands of greedy hospitals.

Salient points of the Supreme Court guideline for hospitals and nursing homes are –


The fact that the unauthorised additional surgery is beneficial for patients, or that it would save considerable time and expense of the patient, or would relieve the patient from pain and suffering in future, are not grounds of defence against charges of negligence or assault.

The only exception to this rule is where the additional procedure though unauthorised, is necessary in order to save the life or preserve the health of the patient and it would be unreasonable to delay such procedure until patient regains consciousness and takes a decision.

Consent given only for diagnostic procedure cannot be considered as consent for therapeutic treatment. Consent given for specific treatment procedure will not be valid for conducting some other treatment procedure.

There can be a common consent for diagnostic and operative procedures when they are contemplated. There can also be a common consent for a particular surgical procedure and an additional or further procedure that may become necessary during the course of surgery.

EN
Written by

Elets News Network

Elets News Network reports on governance, public policy and digital government across India.

IAS Transfer Tracker

Live — 2,066 transfers tracked Updated 12-11-2026, 22:25

The eGov Weekly Briefing

A weekly round-up of governance news, interviews and policy analysis — in your inbox.