News · eGov

A court in Ayodhya has declined to hand over digital evidence filed with the chargesheet to defence counsel in the Ram temple donation theft case, saying the material will be accessible at the appropriate stage of trial.
✦ AI SUMMARY 30-second read

- The court on November 19 refused to provide digital evidence to the defence, with the next hearing scheduled for December 3.
- Investigating officer Ashutosh Tiwari filed a 36,039-page chargesheet on September 23, listing 133 witnesses including names associated with the temple trust.
- The defence sought CCTV footage, audio recordings and donation records from March 2020 to June 30, 2026, arguing it cannot prepare an effective defence without them.
Why it matters: The ruling adds to delays in the start of trial in a case involving alleged theft and misappropriation of donations at one of India's most prominent religious sites.

This summary was generated by AI. Editors may review and update it.
An Ayodhya court on November 19 declined to hand over digital evidence, filed alongside the chargesheet, to defence counsel representing all eight accused in the alleged Ram temple donation theft case. The court observed that the defence would be given adequate opportunity to examine the evidence at the appropriate stage of the trial.

The matter will next be heard on December 3, when the defence counsel is expected to seek additional time to go through the chargesheet, which runs to 36,039 pages. The voluminous nature of the chargesheet and the dispute over digital evidence have been among the factors delaying the start of trial.
What was argued
When the matter came up for hearing, the defence moved an application seeking copies of the entire chargesheet along with all annexures, including the digital material. Defence counsel Kul Shekhar Singh argued that without access to the complete digital evidence, it would not be possible to prepare an effective defence or to cross-examine prosecution witnesses.
The defence had specifically requested CCTV footage and audio recordings from the period of the alleged theft, records of donations and offerings received at the temple from March 2020 to June 30, 2026, and bank receipts along with corresponding bank statements.
Singh said the investigating officer had relied heavily on digital evidence against all eight accused, and that defending them without access to that material would be extremely difficult.
What the court and prosecution said
The prosecution opposed the application, citing the sensitivity of the material and the legal provisions governing the supply of electronic evidence. The court, after hearing both sides, ruled that the defence would receive adequate access at the appropriate stage of proceedings, in accordance with the law.
Legal observers note that under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, the defence is entitled to full access to such material before the trial formally begins, suggesting the refusal is procedural rather than final.
Background to the case
Police registered a case against all eight accused following an investigation into the alleged theft and misappropriation of offerings and donations. After completing the probe, investigating officer Ashutosh Tiwari filed the chargesheet on September 23, accompanied by a list of 133 witnesses.
Among the witnesses named are Champat Rai and Krishna Mohan Rai, who are associated with the temple trust and its affairs. The chargesheet includes documentary evidence, witness statements and the digital evidence now in dispute. Police have stated they possess clinching evidence of the accused's involvement.
What happens next
On December 3, the defence is expected to press for more time to study the voluminous chargesheet and prepare its case. The prosecution is likely to push for framing of charges and the commencement of trial at the earliest opportunity.
Elets will continue to follow developments in this case as the proceedings progress.