News · eGov

Nepal's Supreme Court has refused to register a writ petition filed by Tribhuvan University law students who challenged the institution's use of AI-based plagiarism detection software to reject academic papers.
✦ AI SUMMARY 30-second read

- Supreme Court Registrar Baburam Dahal rejected the writ on Mangsir 2, citing no clear violation of a fundamental or legal right.
- Students Roshan Aauji and Vivek Chaudhary argued that software such as Turnitin and iThenticate wrongly flagged original work as AI-generated.
- Tribhuvan University maintains that anti-plagiarism testing is necessary to protect the originality of research and prevent thesis duplication.
Why it matters: The ruling leaves unresolved questions about student rights, data privacy and AI detection standards in Nepal's higher education system.

This summary was generated by AI. Editors may review and update it.
Nepal's Supreme Court has declined to register a writ petition brought by law students against Tribhuvan University over its policy of rejecting research papers and seminar papers based on results generated by the plagiarism detection tools Turnitin and iThenticate. Supreme Court Registrar Baburam Dahal issued the rejection order on Mangsir 2.

The order stated that because the subject matter concerned the use of technology and academic integrity, and because it was not clear which fundamental or legal right of the petitioners had been violated, the writ could not be admitted for registration. The court cited Section 128 of the Muluki Devani Karyabidhi Sanhita, 2074, and Rule 18(2) of the Supreme Court Regulations, 2074 as the basis for its decision.
The administration held that matters of this nature could not be registered under the court's extraordinary jurisdiction as a public interest litigation.
What was argued
Law students Roshan Aauji and Vivek Chaudhary, among others, filed the petition naming the Office of the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, the Ministry of Education, the Ministry of Defence, and Tribhuvan University as defendants. They sought orders of certiorari and mandamus.
The petitioners contended that in the absence of any law regulating artificial intelligence in Nepal or an official government standard, Tribhuvan University had, through its Rules Relating to Management and Operation of Anti-Plagiarism Software, 2080, undermined students' intellectual work. They argued that the software incorrectly flagged original papers as likely AI-generated, forcing students to rewrite their work multiple times and causing mental stress, with no opportunity to contest the findings.
The writ also raised a data privacy concern, alleging that the storage of students' personal details, keystrokes and digital activity on foreign corporate servers without consent violated Article 28 of the constitution and the Personal Data Protection Act, 2075, thereby increasing cyber security risks.
What the students demanded
Beyond challenging the university's existing policy, the students sought a mandamus directing the formation of a high-level expert committee comprising representatives from law, information technology, cyber security, linguistics and the student community. This committee was to study the actual need and justification for AI detection in the education sector.
The petition additionally requested an interim order suspending Tribhuvan University's operation of AI detection software until a final decision could be reached on the basis of that committee's report.
University's position
Tribhuvan University has maintained that anti-plagiarism testing is essential for ensuring the originality of research and preventing the verbatim copying of theses, describing the software as a safeguard against academic theft.
With the students' writ now rejected at the administrative level, observers note that the underlying dispute over software accuracy, student rights and data privacy remains unresolved, making the matter more complex.
What happens next
The rejection of the writ means Tribhuvan University's anti-plagiarism policy remains in force for the present. Nepal has yet to establish a clear legal framework governing the use of AI tools in academic settings, and no official government standard on the matter exists.
Elets will continue to follow developments on this story.