News · eGov

A co-edited report mapping Chinese AI surveillance across eleven African countries finds more than $2 billion in public-space monitoring spending, with little evidence it reduces terrorism or serious crime.
✦ AI SUMMARY 30-second read

- Research covering eleven African countries identified more than $2 billion spent on public-space surveillance, much of it financed by Chinese companies.
- Uganda's Automated Express Penalty System, launched in June 2025, was suspended within days after public complaints of wrongly attributed fines; a related transport monitoring contract was later declared legally void.
- Researchers found no compelling evidence that smart-city surveillance has reduced terrorism or serious crime across the countries studied.
Why it matters: As African governments spend billions on AI-enabled urban surveillance, weak procurement transparency and absent legal safeguards risk enabling political control over citizens.

This summary was generated by AI. Editors may review and update it.
Uganda switched on its Automated Express Penalty System in June 2025, using CCTV cameras, automatic number plate recognition, and an intelligent transport monitoring system to issue fines to motorists. The system attracted immediate public backlash over duplicated fines, wrongly attributed penalties, and unintentional violations linked to missing speed-limit signs.

The system was suspended within days. On October 6, Uganda's Attorney General Sam Mayanja declared that a 2021 contract with a Russian company for the transport monitoring system, covering digital number plates and vehicle tracking, was legally void and unenforceable. The contractor, Joint Stock Company Global Security, disputes those findings.
The episode forms a central case study in a co-edited report titled Smart City Surveillance in Africa: Mapping Chinese AI Surveillance Across 11 Countries, which examines the expansion and consequences of digital surveillance infrastructure across the continent.
What the report found
The report examined surveillance spending in Algeria, Egypt, Kenya, Mauritius, Mozambique, Nigeria, Rwanda, Senegal, Uganda, Zambia, and Zimbabwe. Researchers identified more than $2 billion in expenditure on the monitoring of public spaces, with much of the financing coming from Chinese companies, though the authors note the real total is likely higher.
The research found no compelling evidence that these systems have reduced terrorism or serious crime in Africa. In Mozambique, surveillance technology described as concentrated in opposition strongholds has not improved official responses to serious crimes such as kidnappings. In Nigeria, heavy spending on surveillance has done little to reduce insecurity.
Senegal and Zambia have invested heavily in these systems despite facing relatively few security threats, the report notes.
Function creep and chilling effects
The researchers document concerns about what they term function creep: the use of systems procured for one purpose to monitor activists, opposition figures, journalists, and protesters. The same unease was recorded in Zimbabwe as well as Uganda.
AI-enabled facial recognition is of particular concern because it allows authorities to track where people go, who they meet, and what public activities they attend, rather than simply recording incidents. Citizens across the countries studied reported self-censoring political expression, and activists described changing travel routes and communication habits in response to surveillance tools whose full capabilities remain unknown.
This pattern was observed not only in countries characterised as more authoritarian, such as Rwanda, Uganda, and Zimbabwe, but also in Kenya, Nigeria, and Zambia, which have more democratic institutions.
Procurement gaps and safeguard failures
The report highlights weak procurement transparency as a key problem. Documents reviewed by researchers show that Uganda's Ministry of Finance found the transport monitoring project's feasibility study inadequate, lacking a proper value-for-money assessment, risk analysis, financial model, and data-protection plan. The system was deployed before those questions were resolved.
The authors argue that contracts for high-risk surveillance systems should be publicly available, alongside financing arrangements, technical specifications, and intended uses. They call for independent human-rights impact assessments before highly intrusive systems are deployed, and for independent evaluation against clearly set objectives and baseline data.
The report also points to a gap in the Declaration of Principles on Freedom of Expression and Access to Information in Africa, published in 2019 by the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights. Its Principle 41 requires legal authorisation and safeguards for communications surveillance but does not extend to mass monitoring in public spaces through cameras, facial recognition, and vehicle tracking.
What happens next
The report calls on Uganda to publish the transport monitoring contract and allow parliament, the auditor general, and the Personal Data Protection Office to assess its costs, capabilities, and safeguards before any form of automated enforcement resumes.
It also calls on countries that export surveillance systems, named as including China, Israel, South Korea, and the United States, to apply stronger human-rights safeguards to their sales and financing arrangements. Civil-society organisations are urged to continue documenting abuses and to support affected communities through digital-security training and legal assistance.
Elets will update this story as developments unfold.