News · eGov

Ukraine's Supreme Court returned a cassation complaint after finding that a lawyer had cited four case numbers that contained no rulings and related to entirely different categories of disputes.
✦ AI SUMMARY 30-second read

- The cassation complaint in a child custody case cited four Supreme Court rulings that did not exist in the official court decisions register.
- The four case numbers belonged to disputes involving contract invalidation, debt recovery, a road traffic offence, and unregistered business activity — not family law.
- The Supreme Court stated it does not prohibit AI use in drafting legal documents but requires lawyers to verify all cited decisions, case numbers, and legal conclusions.
Why it matters: The ruling establishes that lawyers bear full responsibility for verifying AI-generated case citations before filing procedural documents.

This summary was generated by AI. Editors may review and update it.
Ukraine's Supreme Court returned a cassation complaint in a child custody matter after determining that all four judicial decisions cited by the applicant's lawyer did not exist in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions.

The case, bearing the number 523/9632/24, concerned a father's right to participate in raising his minor son and the removal of obstacles to communication with the child. After appellate proceedings, the father's lawyer filed a cassation complaint referencing four prior rulings in support of the legal position taken.
On checking the register, the Supreme Court found that none of the cited case numbers — No. 522/19197/15, No. 761/26645/16-c, No. 753/12866/17, and No. 686/15262/17 — contained any decision by the Supreme Court or the Supreme Court of Ukraine.
What the courts decided
The Peresyp District Court of Odesa partially granted the father's original claim, establishing a transitional visitation schedule under which meetings were to take place in the mother's presence for the first six months, followed by unsupervised contact. The court also obliged the mother not to interfere with the father's communication with the son.
On appeal, the Odesa Court of Appeal upheld the visitation arrangement but overturned the obligation on the mother not to interfere, finding the evidence of interference insufficient given that the parties acknowledged the father was already meeting the son twice a week. The rest of the first-instance ruling remained in force.
The father subsequently filed a cassation complaint arguing that the appellate court had applied provisions of the Family Code of Ukraine and the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine without regard to established Supreme Court conclusions.
What the Supreme Court found
When the court verified the four case numbers cited in the cassation complaint, it found they concerned entirely unrelated disputes: contract invalidation, debt recovery, a road traffic administrative offence, and proceedings related to business activity conducted without state registration.
By its ruling dated 26 March 2026, the Supreme Court returned the cassation complaint. It noted that under Article 389 of the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine, an applicant must clearly specify the legal grounds for cassation, including identifying rulings in which the relevant Supreme Court conclusions actually appear. The absence of properly defined grounds constitutes a basis for return under paragraph 4 of part four of Article 393 of the same Code.
The court's position on artificial intelligence
The Supreme Court used the ruling to set out its view on artificial intelligence in legal practice. It stated that it does not prohibit the use of AI tools in preparing procedural documents but requires that any such use be accompanied by appropriate human oversight and verification.
Lawyers are obliged to confirm the existence of cited decisions, the accuracy of case numbers, and the relevance of quoted legal conclusions to the facts of the dispute at hand. The court also noted that returning a cassation complaint does not bar resubmission once deficiencies are corrected.
After the complaint was returned, the lawyer resubmitted it. The Supreme Court accepted the reasons for missing the cassation deadline as valid, reinstated the deadline, and opened cassation proceedings, also requesting the case materials from the Peresyp District Court of Odesa.
What happens next
Cassation proceedings in case No. 523/9632/24 are now open following the corrected resubmission. The case will proceed on its merits concerning parental participation and child communication rights.
Elets will update this story as further developments emerge.